Forex Zone - Forex Forum

Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory

Discussion started on Technical

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 110
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 8
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Yes, the third phase is the excess phase, where in this phase the followers enter the market after seeing a strong trend in the participatory phase (second phase). Often in this excess phase, followers who are late in entering the market will experience loss because in this phase traders who enter the market in the initial phase have started to distribute (on the upward trend) back the shares they bought or accumulated (in the downtrend) back shares that have been they sell in the initial phase which results in a price correction.
Hmm I still confused with your explanations . Maybe you can give me some examples from market today
#16 - February 23, 2019, 12:39:05 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Measuring Trend With Volume on the Forex Market

There are differences in terms of volume records on the spot forex market with stock markets and stock indices. Uncentralized nature causes currency transactions on the spot currency market (spot forex) not to be recorded. This fact becomes a problem when we will use volume data as one component of analysis, mainly to measure the continuity of a trend or the possibility of a reversal. However, we can use currency transaction data on the currency futures market.

If there is no transaction volume data in the spot forex market, this is not the case with the futures market. All USD exchange transactions with all global currencies, in the forex futures market, are organized by the Chicago Mercantile Exchange and are regulated and supervised by the US CFTC (Commodity Future Trade Commission), and every transaction that occurs is all required to be reported, therefore transaction volume becomes periodically recorded and published (currency in this case as one of the commodities traded).

To get the currency transaction volume data can be obtained every day (daily update) by accessing the CME web in the market data service section, then select volume and open interest then click Daily Volume and Open Interest: http://www.cmegroup.com/ market-data / ... open-interest /. In addition, if you want to get volume data in real time, you can use the platform provided by the CME, but this platform is paid. They also provide a free trial for 2 weeks. To try out the platform can be accessed here: http://www.cmegroup.com/market-data/.../overview.html

Please note, we cannot use volume data on the MT4 platform, because the data on the MT4, regardless of broker, does not reflect the actual transaction volume,

Using volume data on forex as an analysis material, namely by looking at convergence and divergence between price movements and volume movements, when price movements and volume movements are still convergence, the trend will continue, correction or reversal or reversal, will only occur when divergence occurs between price movements and volume movements.

The following is an example when there is a divergence between price movements and volume movements on GBP Globex (Pound on the futures market) a few days ago.


Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy



The picture above can be explained as follows:

- On March 22, 2011, GU reached the highest price around 1.64xx after moving up for 4 consecutive days and the volume recorded at that time amounted to 90968 (the lowest since the price rose during those 4 days, thus divergence occurred with price movements that goes up while the volume movement decreases), since then the GU price moves down to reach 1.59xx on March 28, 2011. When the GU price reaches the lowest at 1.59xx, the transaction volume is recorded at 103512, then divergence returns, the price decreases temporarily volume go up. After that we can see now that GU when I posted this is at level 1.6288. (The image below is the last GU condition, when I wrote this post)


Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy


The chart above uses the CME platform (CME is not a broker, but an institution in the US that organizes commodity futures trading, such as BBJ or Jakarta futures exchange)
#17 - February 23, 2019, 12:40:04 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 110
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 8
  • Reputation: +0/-0
5. Relationship between Volume and Trend

Dow said, volume is one of the important components in the movement in the market, in the bullish trend, it should also be followed by increasing the volume and so when the correction occurs, it should be followed by a decrease in volume.

Volume in market movements, shows the participation of the public (trader) and at the same time also describes an increase in market confidence in a stock when there is an increase in prices accompanied by an increase in volume on the stock. When the bullish trend decreases in volume, it indicates there has been a weakening in the trend and investors have been prepared to take profit which can make a correction move or even a reversal next time.

In addition, the volume also illustrates the strength of supply and demand for a stock as a mirror of the strength of buying interest and selling interest. The upward trend which is still followed by increasing volume or at least followed by stable volume, indicates that there is still more demand or buying interest in a stock.

However, Dow said the volume was not used to predict the direction of the trend, but was used to confirm price movements, "Volume must confirm the trends". He also reminded that without being supported by the volume of volume movements that are in line with the trend of price movements, we do not have to trust the direction of the movement of the market. It can be concluded that volume can be used to measure whether the trend will continue or will change.
Hmmm I still confused with this volume. How can we know the volume up or down ,can you explain? 
#18 - February 23, 2019, 12:44:03 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Hmmm I still confused with this volume. How can we know the volume up or down ,can you explain?
In post # 34 above, if you read carefully, I have given the link, if it is difficult, can also be accessed at this link http://barchart.com/

How:
1. Click the future tab
2. On the left side box, click currencies
3. Select the desired currency (select the contract in June 2011, for example the Euro symbol E6M11) click the chart in the link column (the link column is on the far right)

Next for setting the chart, do the following steps:
1. Symbol E6M11 (Euro) >> Style = Technical >> Template = None >> Frequency = Daily Nearest >> Time Period = 6 months (may be more) >> Date Start and End = Clear >> Size = 900 by 450> > Scale = Linear Scale >> Bar Type = Candle Stick >> Volume = Contract Volume >> Study Size = Large >> Add Study = Commitment of Trader Line Chart (Other indicators can be needed)

2. After the settings above are finished then click Draw Chart

The result and a description of how to see the volume as shown below

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy



If you need another currency, you can just choose the symbol: Pound = B6M11 >> Aud = A6M11 >> Cad = C6M11 >> CHF = S6M11 >> JPY = J6M11 >> NZD = N6M11

Note: For volumes besides being illustrated in the form of bar graphs at the bottom of the chart, there are also figures in the bottom left of the chart.


I hope this helps
#19 - February 23, 2019, 12:45:20 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 110
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 8
  • Reputation: +0/-0
In post # 34 above, if you read carefully, I have given the link, if it is difficult, can also be accessed at this link http://barchart.com/

How:
1. Click the future tab
2. On the left side box, click currencies
3. Select the desired currency (select the contract in June 2011, for example the Euro symbol E6M11) click the chart in the link column (the link column is on the far right)

Next for setting the chart, do the following steps:
1. Symbol E6M11 (Euro) >> Style = Technical >> Template = None >> Frequency = Daily Nearest >> Time Period = 6 months (may be more) >> Date Start and End = Clear >> Size = 900 by 450> > Scale = Linear Scale >> Bar Type = Candle Stick >> Volume = Contract Volume >> Study Size = Large >> Add Study = Commitment of Trader Line Chart (Other indicators can be needed)

2. After the settings above are finished then click Draw Chart

The result and a description of how to see the volume as shown below



If you need another currency, you can just choose the symbol: Pound = B6M11 >> Aud = A6M11 >> Cad = C6M11 >> CHF = S6M11 >> JPY = J6M11 >> NZD = N6M11

Note: For volumes besides being illustrated in the form of bar graphs at the bottom of the chart, there are also figures in the bottom left of the chart.


I hope this helps
Most of us trade on the MT4 platform, so we know about where the Volume Data is?
Continue to be mentioned in the picture if Volume above 100000 will be divergent and correction will be completed, if Volume below 90000 correction will continue, this is based on being able to determine Volume values of 100000 and 90000?
Please explain.

#20 - February 23, 2019, 12:49:59 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Most of us trade on the MT4 platform, so we know about where the Volume Data is?
Continue to be mentioned in the picture if Volume above 100000 will be divergent and correction will be completed, if Volume below 90000 correction will continue, this is based on being able to determine Volume values of 100000 and 90000?
Please explain.
Please read again carefully and slowly post # 34 and post # 38 above, so that I do not explain it repeatedly, in those two posts I have clearly explained it. Thank you...
#21 - February 23, 2019, 12:50:35 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 110
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 8
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Please read again carefully and slowly post # 34 and post # 38 above, so that I do not explain it repeatedly, in those two posts I have clearly explained it. Thank you...
Ohh Sorry sir, it turns out that when I posted my inbox, it was posted after it was answered in post # 38 ...
 

This one is quite clear and I have practiced it.
Just what is still the question about Volume 100000 and 90000, maybe the reasons for this value can be explained?
Thanks for the explanation.
#22 - February 23, 2019, 12:53:48 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Ohh Sorry sir, it turns out that when I posted my inbox, it was posted after it was answered in post # 38 ...
 

This one is quite clear and I have practiced it.
Just what is still the question about Volume 100000 and 90000, maybe the reasons for this value can be explained?
Thanks for the explanation.
The key words are:
- Divergence = The direction of price movements and the direction of the opposite volume movement, then when this condition occurs, a reversal of the price movement will occur immediately. Observe the bold sentence above.

- Convergence = The direction of price movements and the direction of movement of the volume are the same, if this situation still occurs, then price movements will continue in the same direction.

If when the price at the level of 1.59xx is below the volume of 90,000, it means the direction of the volume movement will be the same as the direction of price movements, both moving downwards, because at the first time a price correction declined from the level of 1.64xx in volume of 90,968. Conversely, if it turns out the volume is above 100,000 when the price reaches the lowest at the level of 1.59xx, it means that there is a divergence between falling price movements while the volume moves up from 90,968 to above 100,000, thus the correction will be finished and prices will move up again. In fact the volume turned out to be over 100,000 so the correction was completed and prices rose again to this day.

With these guidelines, we can make a decision to enter when there is a signal that a reversal will occur, that is when a divergence condition occurs.

But keep in mind, this is only one component of the analysis tool, there are still other components that will still be discussed.
#23 - February 23, 2019, 12:54:24 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 110
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 8
  • Reputation: +0/-0
The key words are:
- Divergence = The direction of price movements and the direction of the opposite volume movement, then when this condition occurs, a reversal of the price movement will occur immediately. Observe the bold sentence above.

- Convergence = The direction of price movements and the direction of movement of the volume are the same, if this situation still occurs, then price movements will continue in the same direction.

If when the price at the level of 1.59xx is below the volume of 90,000, it means the direction of the volume movement will be the same as the direction of price movements, both moving downwards, because at the first time a price correction declined from the level of 1.64xx in volume of 90,968. Conversely, if it turns out the volume is above 100,000 when the price reaches the lowest at the level of 1.59xx, it means that there is a divergence between falling price movements while the volume moves up from 90,968 to above 100,000, thus the correction will be finished and prices will move up again. In fact the volume turned out to be over 100,000 so the correction was completed and prices rose again to this day.

With these guidelines, we can make a decision to enter when there is a signal that a reversal will occur, that is when a divergence condition occurs.

But keep in mind, this is only one component of the analysis tool, there are still other components that will still be discussed.
to find out the price correction how to pack (in what condition) ... if in the above conditions there is a decrease from point 1.64xx 3 consecutive candles, .. after that there is a disvergence. in this case for the exact time we are looking for a formation candles similar to this, in the sense that they do not apply to sideways conditions, for example candle 1 up, candle 2 bears continue up again ... etc. and for TF, which is used well, how many sirs? can it be used for small TFs? explanation please.. thanks ..
#24 - February 23, 2019, 12:57:57 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Analysis of Peak and Valley in Trend

Peak and valley analysis (Peak and Through) is basically used for the purpose of knowing trends and reversals of the price movements of a market. The trend is both uptrend and downtrend.

a. Trend Increases Vs Down Trend

Bullish Trends

A trend is said to increase if the price is always able to pass the peak (peak) or Higher High and is always able to form a new peak or Higher High (HH) where the new peak or Higher High (HH) is always higher than peak or Higher High before. Then followed by valleys (through) or Low which are higher than previous Low (Higher Low / HL)

Industrial image of bullish trend.
Quote

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy



A trend is said to decrease if the price is always able to go through the valley (through) or Lower Low (LL) and is always able to form new valleys (through) or Lower Low (LL) where the new valley (through) or Lower Low (LL) is always lower than the valley or Lower Low before. Then followed by the peak (peak) or High which is lower than the previous High (Low High / LH)

Industrial image of bullish trend.

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy


Tend analysis with peak / HH identification and valley or LL use at least on TF daily (lowest)
#25 - February 23, 2019, 12:59:13 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
to find out the price correction how to pack (in what condition) ... if in the above conditions there is a decrease from point 1.64xx 3 consecutive candles, .. after that there is a disvergence. in this case for the exact time we are looking for a formation candles similar to this, in the sense that they do not apply to sideways conditions, for example candle 1 up, candle 2 bears continue up again ... etc. and for TF, which is used well, how many sirs? can it be used for small TFs? explanation please.. thanks ..
To be called a correction or reversal of the price movement, when the reversal or correction occurs, the price is in a clear direction of movement, up or down. When prices are in conditions as you call above, up and down candles, these are usually called side ways or flat, where prices move sideways or move in a range. Then when the price exits the range, it is usually called a break out. To confirm whether or not valid break out is one of them by looking at the volume changes that occur, if it is supported by increasing volume it can be said that the break out is valid.

TF is used to see minimal trends and reversals on the daily TF. To break out, depending on the TF, what side side conditions occur, if it occurs on the intraday TF, for example TF H1, then if there is a break out which is confirmed by an increase in volume, of course it can enter / enter TF H1, but with a break if out in the opposite direction to the trend on the daily TF, have to exit that day or with a small target, and if the price breaks out from the range price in accordance with the trend direction on the daily TF, then you can hold the position or the target can be set bigger .

Once again I remind you, that the new volume is one component of the entire analysis tool using the Dow theory. It will be more comprehensive if integrated with trend analysis etc., which will be discussed next.
#26 - February 23, 2019, 12:59:58 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 110
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 8
  • Reputation: +0/-0
To be called a correction or reversal of the price movement, when the reversal or correction occurs, the price is in a clear direction of movement, up or down. When prices are in conditions as you call above, up and down candles, these are usually called side ways or flat, where prices move sideways or move in a range. Then when the price exits the range, it is usually called a break out. To confirm whether or not valid break out is one of them by looking at the volume changes that occur, if it is supported by increasing volume it can be said that the break out is valid.

TF is used to see minimal trends and reversals on the daily TF. To break out, depending on the TF, what side side conditions occur, if it occurs on the intraday TF, for example TF H1, then if there is a break out which is confirmed by an increase in volume, of course it can enter / enter TF H1, but with a break if out in the opposite direction to the trend on the daily TF, have to exit that day or with a small target, and if the price breaks out from the range price in accordance with the trend direction on the daily TF, then you can hold the position or the target can be set bigger .

Once again I remind you, that the new volume is one component of the entire analysis tool using the Dow theory. It will be more comprehensive if integrated with trend analysis etc., which will be discussed next.
while the post is still fresh ... what about the impact news on the movement of the pair and its volume, sir? except if there is no news ... we can still use the fibo benchmark or line resistance support ... (which is more relevant to the thread) sorry if my question came out a little ...
#27 - February 23, 2019, 01:03:48 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
while the post is still fresh ... what about the impact news on the movement of the pair and its volume, sir? except if there is no news ... we can still use the fibo benchmark or line resistance support ... (which is more relevant to the thread) sorry if my question came out a little ...
Dow says, "price movements reflect everything (Price Discounted Everything)". Whatever information and news develops has been reflected in price movements, even Dow said, "the most important thing is, not what can cause prices to move now, but what reactions might occur to current price movements.

But we are not Dow, so am I, not as far as the nail of Charles H. Dow. Like it or not, in fact when the news comes out, prices often move regardless of the direction of the trend, as well as the volume becomes as useless, but often too, if the direction is contrary to the trend supported by volume, after that the price will move again according to the direction of the trend.

For those who intraday treding will be a problem when its position is contrary to price movements after news, and it is not a problem for those swing or short term trading who hold positions for days in accordance with the trend direction, because price movements in response to the news still cannot change direction major trend movement. .
#28 - February 23, 2019, 01:04:34 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 104
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 4
  • Reputation: +0/-0
b. Beginning and End of Trend (Reversal)

Reversal of the upward trend (bullish)

When the downtrend, the price is no longer able to pass or break Lower Low (LL) and then form a higher Low (LH), then followed by the ability of the price to break (Lower) and then form a higher High (HH), thus, this indicates that there has been a reversal of price movements, and new trends have begun from down to up trend (or it can be a form from the beginning of the correction)

Then after the price then moves up (bullish) then at a certain point then the price is no longer able to break Higher High to form a higher Higher High, but instead the High is formed lower than the previous High or lower Lower or High is formed from the previous High (LH), the up trend has ended, then there will be a reversal of the price movement.

Illustrated picture of the beginning and end of the trend

Quote
Spoiler title=SpoilerSpoiler:
Classical Technical Analysis Using Dow Theory in Technical_proxy

#29 - February 23, 2019, 01:05:38 PM

  • Full Member
  • Posts: 110
  • Points: 0
  • Likes Received: 8
  • Reputation: +0/-0
Dow says, "price movements reflect everything (Price Discounted Everything)". Whatever information and news develops has been reflected in price movements, even Dow said, "the most important thing is, not what can cause prices to move now, but what reactions might occur to current price movements.

But we are not Dow, so am I, not as far as the nail of Charles H. Dow. Like it or not, in fact when the news comes out, prices often move regardless of the direction of the trend, as well as the volume becomes as useless, but often too, if the direction is contrary to the trend supported by volume, after that the price will move again according to the direction of the trend.

For those who intraday treding will be a problem when its position is contrary to price movements after news, and it is not a problem for those swing or short term trading who hold positions for days in accordance with the trend direction, because price movements in response to the news still cannot change direction major trend movement. .
slowly sir .. is the criterion of a valid volume index? What does it mean is there a definite count for this volume ... for disvergence and its convergence ... if there is a value, sir ... previously posted an example chart not taken from the metatrader, can it be applied in the MetaRetrer pack, considering that in the meta there is also an index volume ... to get a small TF from the chart above, where are you?
#30 - February 23, 2019, 01:08:30 PM

Members:

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.